top of page

The Bedrock
Ancient Stories and Ancient Storytelling techniques

Unadaptable Odysseus: 
Christopher Nolan vs. Homer?

September 1, 2026

 

Paul Bednarowski

​

Homer’s Odysseus is one of the most famous heroes of western literature, but he made even the ancients uncomfortable. By the time he appears in Greek tragedies, he is a scheming, amoral villain. There is something about Homer’s Odysseus that has always rubbed us the wrong way.

​

                

In Christopher Nolan’s Odyssey (2026), Matt Damon’s Odysseus is hard to dislike. He is a little impulsive, taking one last, angry shot at the cyclops that leads to more deaths. He is a little unsentimental, willing to leave a man behind if it means saving the rest. He is a realist, less interested in the gods than in making his own fate (though ultimately willing to give himself over to the divine). He is ever devoted to wife and home; only drugs can make him forget. His crew may doubt him, but he never gives up on his crew, and he remains an unparalleled fighter after all these years. In other words, he is the hero in an American epic film. His failings are entirely understandable and human, and you can root for him.

                 

Homer’s Odysseus is less likable. We meet him pining for home and desperate to return to his wife because he has grown tired of sleeping with goddesses. He returns to tame the suitors and rule the people of Ithaca but repeatedly fails to manage his Ithacan crew or save them from danger until they are all dead. He was a hero of the Trojan War but spends the last half of the Odyssey disguised as an old beggar, a form that may come too close to the truth given his years of fighting and wandering. He passes long stretches of time being abused by the suitors and their servants, frustrated and unable to respond.

                 

Suspense and a supporting cast make Odysseus the hero we find in Homer. We know that Nolan’s Odysseus will win. Almost everyone is familiar with the story of Homer’s Odyssey, but it has its roots in oral storytelling where success depended on adapting traditional stories in new ways to hold audiences rapt. Suspense is baked in and continues to work in reading after reading. When Homer’s Odysseus faces the suitors and meets Penelope, we want him to succeed but cannot be sure that he will. He needs to infiltrate the palace undetected through cunning and endure the abuse of the suitors without revealing himself. He must face the suitors in battle and prove worthy of his wife. These are exactly the qualities he has trouble within the epic.

                 

Homer’s Odysseus is clever enough to outsmart and escape the cyclops but cannot resist revealing his identity in anger, bringing the wrath of Poseidon down on himself and his crew. Will he be able to restrain his anger when the suitors insult him and threaten those around him? Odysseus cannot control his crew. How will he fare with the suitors not to mention his small band of allies? In Homer, Odysseus tries to fight Scylla head-on and fails, getting more men killed in the process. Will he be foolish enough to do the same in the palace? Although we see Odysseus win a discuss throw and defeat a fellow beggar for scraps, his days on the battlefield are long behind him. We have no idea how he will do against the so many suitors. Does Odysseus care about Penelope? He has stopped to sleep with goddesses and is offered the hand of a young woman along the way. What will Penelope think of him looking every bit the battered veteran and seadog he pretends to be? Odysseus has more than enough heroic qualities to keep us interested in his story, but his deep-running imperfections and the possibility of failure are what keep us wanting more.

               

Homeric Odysseus can disappoint us because Telemachus and Penelope are there to pick up the pieces. Most are surprised to find that Odysseus does not even appear in the beginning of Homer’s Odyssey, but we find ourselves invested begrudgingly in the story of a young man trying to find his place in society and a woman forced to use what little power she has to outmaneuver the men around her. As Odysseus’s story lags, Telemachus and Penelope gain prominence, often displaying the same powers of cunning, endurance, and loyalty that drew us to Odysseus’s famous story in the first place. Nolan has training scenes for Telemachus and includes Penelope’s nightly unravelling of the shroud to put off marriage, but he cuts scenes where they actively compete with Odysseus: Penelope in her finest to fill suitors with desire and make them offer more gifts, Penelope outsmarting and recognizing Odysseus, Telemachus on the verge of stringing Odysseus’s bow, Odysseus, Telemachus, and Odysseus’s father, Laertes, facing off against the suitors’ families when they come seeking revenge.

Christopher Nolan has adapted a story that was itself an adaptation of earlier, unrecorded myths.

 

Like the best adaptors, he has reshaped the story to bring out elements that resonate with contemporary audiences—rousing adventure, action, drama, and the triumph of good over evil, but also the cost of war, processing trauma, and the possibility that we tell ourselves entertaining stories to distract from the damage we inflict at home and abroad. But to do this he has given us an unchallenging Odysseus and a story more familiar than Homer’s.

bottom of page