The Bedrock
Ancient Stories and Ancient Storytelling techniques
Reassurance and Doubt in Homer’s Odyssey:
Narrative Suspense as Compositional Tool
Reassurance and Doubt in Homer’s Odyssey:
Narrative Suspense as Compositional Tool (Final Submission to Hermes, 5/9/21)
Abstract: Our Odyssey is shaped by oral poetics but also by storytelling techniques developed to attract and hold the audience’s attention. From Odysseus’ first appearance, episodes consistently bring to mind his revenge plot against the suitors and test the qualities and skills he will need to carry it out. These episodes offer reassuring evidence that Odysseus will defeat the suitors balanced by doubt-inducing signs that he will fail. Taken together, these episodes elicit hope and fear, the constituent elements of suspense, regarding Odysseus’ chances of succeeding. The consistency with which these episodes appear and the balance they strike between reassurance and doubt suggest that the generation of suspense played a significant role in the composition of the Odyssey as we have it.
Key Words: Homer, Odyssey, Odysseus, Oral Poetics, suspense, Narrative Emotions, Ancient Epic
Our Odyssey is the product of oral poetics and of writing, but it is also the product of storytelling.[1] One of the clearest indications of the poets’ interest in engaging audiences’ attention is how they tailored performances to suit both audience and setting. As Steiner observes, “the oral poet could compose ex tempore, fashioning an original song each time he performed by using pre-existing elements, which he would expand, curtail, reorder and modify at will and in accordance with audience expectations and demands” (2010: 3).[2] Given a short interlude, a singer could perform a brief song like those of Demodocus in Odyssey 8. With more time and a more receptive audience—the Phaeacians, enthralled by Odysseus’ story and willing to listen until dawn—a poet could expand upon the story indefinitely. The version of the Odyssey Odysseus tells Penelope (23.310-41) stands at one end of the spectrum, the Odyssey as we have it on the other. Oral theory proposes mechanisms for the expansion of songs, including detailed descriptions, type-scenes, and additional, thematically appropriate episodes within the story pattern.[3] But, unless poets sought only to test their audiences’ patience, expansion could not be an end in itself.[4] Holding the audience’s attention and, if possible, increasing their interest and investment in the narrative had to be at least part of the equation.
This article attempts to bridge the gap between what we know about the oral nature of the Odyssey and what we know about storytelling. I focus on the generation of suspense, one of the most common and important techniques for holding audiences’ attention, and offer evidence to support the view that suspense was part of the process of composition and expansion.[5] Critics have drawn attention to isolated stories and episodes in the Odyssey that look to the epic’s conclusion and appear to address how, and how well, Odysseus will achieve his nostos.[6] These instances are neither isolated nor incidental. They occur with sufficient frequency and specificity to suggest that they are a significant part of how and why our Odyssey looks the way it does. Odysseus’ nostos in the Odyssey is twofold: to defeat the suitors and to reunite with Penelope. This article focuses only on scenes that address Odysseus’ slaughter of the suitors; it analyzes how earlier scenes look ahead to the revenge plot and how they encourage either the hope that Odysseus will carry it out successfully or the fear that he will prove unequal to the task—hope and fear, the constituent elements of suspense. Odysseus’ experience in the Phaeacian games and his encounter with Irus evince this pattern in miniature.
NARRATIVE REPETITION
Oral theorists offer explanations that could otherwise account for situations and themes in earlier episodes that mirror elements of the murder of the suitors and reunion with Penelope. Albert Lord argued that oral poets composed in accordance with large-scale patterns that developed from “the logic of the narrative” and “the consequent force of habitual association” (1960: 96-97) and aided both the composition and appreciation of the poems[7]; Mary Lord observed that these themes are often reproduced in episodes within the larger pattern: Chryses’ ransom of Chryseis from Agamemnon and the story of Meleager establish the pattern of withdrawal and return that Achilles will fulfil over the course of the Iliad; Odysseus’s and the other heroes’ nostoi in the Odyssey likewise “follow some parts of our story pattern” (1967: 243-44). Louden detects an “extended narrative pattern” in the Phaiakis and Apologue that is based on the palace sequence on Ithaca (1999: 3). The pattern includes, among other things, “hidden identity” and “abuse by young men followed by their destruction” (Louden 1999: 2).[8]
Alden’s examination of “para-narratives”[9] in the Odyssey demonstrates how frequently the events of the principal (i.e., present-time) narrative of Odysseus’s homecoming are echoed by other narrative strains.[10] Alden argues, for example, that the Apologue “advertises the tactics and methods to be used (as well as to be avoided) in confronting the situation at home in Ithaca” (2017: 75). Alden is invaluable for scenes and elements in the Odyssey that reflect on its conclusion but often interprets them in terms of what they teach Odysseus rather than how they function for the audience or for the poet.[11] The work of Hopman on the Apologue comes closest to the approach I take in this article. Hopman argues that the Cyclops episode demonstrates Odysseus’s ability to overcome a superior force through metis and suggests that he will be able to defeat the suitors through similar means; on the other hand, his failure to overcome Scylla through force or cunning “may have raised, if only for a moment, the possibility of an un-traditional outcome for the poem—that Odysseus’ cunning be not enough to triumph over the suitors, and that the hero be defeated by an enemy collectively stronger than he” (Hopman 2012: 24-26).[12] Hopman views these instances as narratological “seeds” for the revenge: “an earlier piece of information which makes a later event more natural, logical, or plausible” (2012: 24). I argue that these are two instances of a larger narrative pattern, in which the poet recreates essential circumstances or alludes to Odysseus’s defeat of the suitors to offer reassurance or introduce doubts regarding his ability to carry it out. The goal is to keep in mind and to generate suspense regarding the outcome of the revenge story.
SUSPENSE
The construction of a suspenseful narrative is not inconsistent with other structuring devices, oral or otherwise, and likely developed in tandem with them. The standard view of suspense holds that “people feel suspense when they fear a bad outcome, hope for a good outcome, and are uncertain about which outcome will come to pass.”[13] It is worth distinguishing at the outset narrative suspense, the kind of suspense with which this article is concerned, from more discrete, situational suspense that centers on immediate questions—Will she win the contest? Will she evade detection? Will something jump out?—and is often dismissed as sub-literary, its effect most likely to dissipate after repeated engagements. Narrative suspense structures entire works and rewards repeated engagement.[14] It requires not only establishing an outcome or goal that audiences deem desirable or “good,”[15] but also a means of achieving it that audiences value or admire and a protagonist an audience would, at the very least, not begrudge the success.[16]
The Odyssey establishes early on the desirable prospect of seeing a man carry out justified revenge against those who threaten his family. It encourages further investment in this outcome through the accumulation of evidence for Odysseus’s worthiness as a protagonist (desirable qualities, divine support), for Penelope’s desirability as a spouse (cleverness, loyalty, beauty, like-mindedness), and for the suitors’ need to be stopped (appropriation, wastefulness, abusiveness, impiety, attempted murder, deception).[17] The manner in which Odysseus will achieve his revenge takes shape as the narrative proceeds both through explicit discussion and through parallel exempla.[18] It becomes clear that he will need both cunning and endurance to infiltrate the palace and to maintain his disguise in the face of beloved members of the household, including his own wife (16.299-304), and despite the suitors’ abuse (16.274-80); Odysseus will require cunning to disarm and surprise the suitors (cf. Od. 16.282-98) but also strength to defeat them in battle (cf. Od. 16.243-57; 22.144ff.); because of the odds against him, Odysseus will not be able to defeat the suitors by himself (cf. 16.237-39)[19] and will need to be able to distinguish between allies and enemies in the palace and to manage the allies he enlists.
With their desirable goals achieved through culturally approved skills and dispositions, even the brief accounts of Hephaestus’s revenge against Ares and Aphrodite and Odysseus’s exploits in Troy offer the kernel around which a poet could build an extended, suspenseful narrative. One might expand them simply by delaying the desired outcome through added details or episodes, but delay, in itself, is not enough to maintain audience interest and might distract unnecessarily from the principal narrative. In the Odyssey, three factors ensure that episodes generate suspense while keeping the endpoint of the narrative in mind, in this case, Odysseus’s final confrontation with the suitors: whether drawn from a repository of Odysseus stories, borrowed from another hero, or invented for the occasion, additional episodes 1) bring to mind the final confrontation or mirror defining elements closely enough to encourage recall when it takes place; 2) test a disposition or skill crucial to Odysseus’s success in the endeavor; and 3) offer either reassurance that Odysseus will defeat the suitors through a successful display or introduce doubt through failure. A new episode might pit Odysseus against young men like the suitors, show him outnumbered or outmatched, or force him to deal with an ambush. It might test his ability to outsmart stronger enemies, escape detection, stand against an enemy in battle, or enlist allies to help him.[20] Achieving a balance between episodes that introduce doubt and those that offer reassurance is both crucial and delicate: too much reassurance gives the impression of a foregone conclusion and a goal so attainable that it is hardly worth pursuing; too much doubt about the feasibility of the goal risks discouraging audiences or making the victory feel unearned or unbelievable. In what follows, I look at episodes involving circumstances, skills or dispositions that are essential to Odysseus’s revenge plot and examine whether they provide reassuring evidence that Odysseus possesses the qualities and skills that he will require or suggest the possibility of failure through the worrisome lack thereof. I argue that the consistent distribution of these episodes throughout the Odyssey and the interplay between reassuring and doubt-inducing elements point to the role that suspense played in shaping its narrative.
THE STORIES OF MENELAUS AND HELEN
With their accounts of disguised infiltrations of enemy territory and examples of cunning used to surprise and destroy a superior force, the stories of Helen and Menelaus offer a clear blueprint for how Odysseus might face the suitors and suggest that he, of all heroes, is best suited for the task.[21] Helen’s story of Odysseus’s infiltration of Troy (4.244-58) shows his commitment and ability to disguise himself. He willingly subjects himself to “unseemly blows” (αὐτόν μιν πληγῇσιν ἀεικελίῃσι δαμάσσας, 4.244) and succeeds in deceiving his targets—the Trojans take no notice of him and say not a word (ἀβάκησαν, 4.249). Although Helen claims to have recognized him, Odysseus remains undeterred and deflects her through cunning (κερδοσύνῃ ἀλέεινεν, 4.252). He confirms her suspicions and reveals his mission only after she has sworn a “mighty oath” to keep his secret (4.252-56). He slays many Trojans before returning safely to the Greeks with intelligence (4.257-258). On the basis of this story, Odysseus will be able to use a disguise to enter the palace undetected, and he will maintain it even if he raises the suspicions of those who know him best. If Odysseus is willing to injure himself for the sake of a disguise, the suitors ineffectual abuse is unlikely to trouble him. If it comes to blows, Odysseus should be able to handle young, drunken suitors at least as effectively as trained Trojan warriors. In Helen’s telling, the detection of Odysseus appears more a testament to her powers of perception than a failure on the part of Odysseus; the subsequent revelation that Helen had already become disenchanted with life in Troy and rejoiced at Odysseus’s victory (4.259-64) lends support after the fact to Odysseus’s decision to trust her.
Menelaus’s story of Odysseus and the other Greeks inside the Trojan Horse and Helen’s impersonation of their wives (4.270-89) offers further proof of Odysseus’s ability to deal with the suitors but also introduces the worrisome possibility that Odysseus’s faith in Helen is misplaced. Menelaus’s account reminds the audience that Odysseus played an integral part in the most famous stratagem every devised for infiltrating heavily defended territory and taking an enemy by surprise (4.271-73); the architect of the Trojan Horse should be able to sneak into his own palace and take by surprise a group of rowdy young men. Odysseus’s comportment in the horse shows that he can resist traps and temptations to reveal his identity. His ability to resist the lure of his wife’s voice when others cannot (4.278-79; 4.282-84, 286-87) suggests that the prospect of a reunion with the wife he has not seen for twenty years will not distract him from addressing a more pressing danger (cf. 13.333-36). His successful silencing of Anticlus may come to mind when he is forced to act quickly after Eurycleia recognizes him in the presence of Penelope (19.466-80).[22] Odysseus’s action on behalf of his allies, which “saved all of the Greeks” (4.288), suggests that he will be able to work alongside Ithacan allies and ensure their safety as well as his own. But Helen’s appearance alongside a new Trojan husband (4.276) and her attempt to ferret out the Greeks belie the earlier claim that her “heart had turned to going back home” (μοι κραδίη τέτραπτο νέεσθαι ἂψ οἶκόνδ᾽, 4.260-61) and invite a reevaluation of the trust Odysseus places in her. This raises questions about Odysseus’s ability to distinguish between allies and enemies, particularly when they are women he knows well (Alden 2017: 167), concerns likely to reemerge in his interview with Penelope.
THE PHAEACIANS
Odysseus’s time among the Phaeacians shows his ability to enlist allies even under the most unlikely circumstances,[23] but the episode also addresses whether he retains his heroic strength, whether he can navigate social interactions with arrogant, insolent young nobles not unlike the suitors, and whether he can restrain himself in the face of nostalgia. Athena and others have made it clear that the old Odysseus could easily vanquish the suitors (1.254-66), but Alcinous’s assessment of Odysseus’s physical condition is mixed: his build is not bad (φυήν γε μὲν οὐ κακός ἐστι) and he “does not lack the vigor of youth” (οὐδέ τι ἥβης δεύεται), but he has been broken by many evils (8.134-37). Both Alcinous and Odysseus support the view that Odysseus has been diminished. Alcinous observes that “nothing else breaks a man down worse than the sea, even if he is strong (οὐ γὰρ ἐγώ γέ τί φημι κακώτερον ἄλλο θαλάσσης | ἄνδρα γε συγχεῦαι, εἰ καὶ μάλα καρτερὸς εἴη8.138-39). Odysseus affirms that (8.180-83),
ἐν πρώτοισιν ὀίω
ἔμμεναι, ὄφρ’ ἥβῃ τε πεποίθεα χερσͅι τ’ ἐμῇσι.
νῦν δ’ ἔχομαι κακότητι καὶ ἄλγεσι· πολλὰ γὰρ ἔτλην
ἀνδρῶν τε πτολέμους ἀλεγεινά τε κύματα πείρων.
I think I was among the first
as long as I had faith in my youth and hands,
but now I’m beset by evils and pain because I’ve endured many things,
making my way through wars of men and harrowing waves.
Euryalus suggests that Odysseus looks more like a merchant captain than an athlete (8.159-64). But, after finally deciding to compete, Odysseus picks up a larger and heavier discus than any Phaeacians’, hurls it “from his mighty hand” (στιβαρῆς ἀπὸ χειρός), and easily surpasses the other competitors’ marks—no Phaeacian could even come close (8.186-98). This scene echoes in miniature the suspenseful structure of the larger narrative and affirms for the first time that Odysseus retains at least some portion of the strength he demonstrated as a hero in the Trojan War. It lends some support, limited though it may be,[24] to the view that he could vanquish the suitors in battle (see Nagler 1990: 349).
More troubling with regard to the suitors is Odysseus’s inability to deal calmly with the young Phaeacians.[25] Interpreting Laodamas’s invitation to join the games as an insult (κερτομέοντες, 8.153), he first dismisses the jibe; he has more serious things to worry about than athletic contests (8.154-57).[26] But when Euryalus challenges him directly (νείκεσέ τ᾽ ἄντην) and mocks him (8.158-64), Odysseus insults Euryalus’s judgment and grace, accuses him of rudeness, and, against his better judgement, takes up the challenge (8.165-85). After proving himself, he goes on to challenge any Phaeacian who dares, with the exception of his host, and comes close to revealing his identity with specific references to Philoctetes and the Trojan War (8.202-33); only the intervention of Alcinous prevents Odysseus from taking the matter further. The suitors have proven that they are not above abusing hosts and guests alike in the palace. A similar inability to withstand the goading of arrogant young men and desire to prove himself would quickly reveal Odysseus’s identity and bring the suitors down upon him before he could enact his plan.
The Odyssey presents the revelation of Odysseus’s identity on Phaeacia as a cathartic climax to an extended period of dramatic irony. But the circumstances under which Odysseus’s identity comes to light nevertheless raise questions about his ability to carry out his revenge against the suitors.[27] After Demodocus sings of the quarrel of Odysseus and Achilles, Odysseus draws his cloak over his face to conceal his tears from the Phaeacians (8.83-86). When Demodocus renews his song after a brief intermission, Odysseus again covers his head and weeps aloud (γοάασκεν). Only Alcinous “perceived and considered” (ἐπεφράσατ' ἠδ' ἐνόησεν) Odysseus’s groaning (8.94-95 = 532-34) and tactfully suggests a different activity. After an extended interlude, Odysseus praises Demodocus and proposes unprompted a song about the Trojan Horse (8.493-95). This time, Odysseus “melts” (τήκετο) in response to the song and drenches his cheeks in tears (ἔδευεν ὑπὸ βλεφάροισι παρειάς, 8.522) like a woman about to be enslaved, wailing over her dead husband after the fall of her city (8.521-31). In spite of this display, Alcinous is once more the only person to observe Odysseus (8.532-36; 532-34 = 8.94-95), but he brings the matter to the attention of those around him; he stops Demodocus (8.537-40) and insists that Odysseus reveal his name and homeland so the Phaeacians can escort him home (8.548-56; see Rinon 2006: 217), which Odysseus in fact does at the beginning of the next book. The satisfaction of seeing the Phaeacians finally realize that they are hosting the very hero about whom Demodocus has been singing may distract momentarily from the realization that Odysseus’s attraction to stories about his past and inability to control himself when he hears them have revealed his identity. He miscalculates not only his self-control when faced with his past but also his ability to conceal his reactions from others. Odysseus’s weakness for the past might lead audience members to wonder every time he meets a loved one on Ithaca and especially during his interview with Penelope.[28] These fears would be confirmed when, even before stepping foot in the palace, Odysseus cannot help but shed a tear for his old hunting dog, Argos. Odysseus proves able to hold back his tears when he meets with Penelope (19.209-12)[29] but reveals himself to Eurycleia through a different kind of miscalculation.
APOLOGUE
The Apologue offers rousing evidence that Odysseus possesses the heroic cunning and endurance he will need to face the suitors and is likely to “bolster his—and the narratees’—confidence with regard to his final ‘adventure’, his arrival home” (de Jong 2001: 221).[30] The Cyclops episode offers some of the most concrete evidence that Odysseus will be able to evade threats in the palace and dispatch the suitors despite the odds against him[31]: Odysseus foresees the threat posed by the Cyclops (9.213-15)[32] and thinks to bring the wine he will need to subdue him; he detects Polyphemus’s trap and lies to keep the rest of his allies safe (9.281, 283-87); the “Outis” ploy prevents the intervention of the other Cyclops (9.364-70, 399-414), and Odysseus successfully carries out his blinding, binding plan to escape Polyphemus’s cave and evade detection.[33]
If the episode itself is promising, Odysseus’s preparation for and final boast over the feat reveal qualities that would lead to problems among the suitors. Odysseus is committed to testing the Cyclopes (τῶν ἀνδρῶν πειρήσομαι, 9.174) but badly misjudges and underestimates his would-be host. Setting aside earlier suspicions and resisting his men’s advice (9.224-28), he boldly enters a space to which he believes he has a right (9.224-29, 268).[34] Odysseus’s presumption that his host will adhere to the traditions of xenia through goodwill or fear (9.229, 267-71) proves misguided, and his crew suffers dearly for it.[35] Odysseus has every reason to expect a warm welcome from at least some of the inhabitants of his own palace, but we have already seen the suitors’ willingness to flout customs surrounding xenia to the extent that they attempt to murder their own host. If in testing the suitors and their servants (cf. 16.305-7) Odysseus puts as much faith in their adherence to custom as he does Polyphemus’, a continuation of the pattern established in this episode would quickly lead to a disastrous end for Odysseus’s allies if not for himself.
Odysseus’s need not only to punish Polyphemus’s actions but also to take credit for doing so reinforces the portrayal of Odysseus in the Phaeacian games and provides a template for how his identity might be revealed prematurely in response to the suitors’ abuse. Despite executing a brilliant escape, Odysseus cannot help but “gloat over his victory” (Stanford [1954] 1967: 77-78).[36] Falsely believing himself and his crew out of danger, Odysseus mocks the Cyclops, claiming to have carried out divinely apportioned revenge (9.474-79) and goading the Cyclops to hurl a rock that almost destroys Odysseus’s ship outright and begins to draw it back to shore. Undeterred by the result of his actions or by his crew’s attempt to dissuade him, Odysseus’s proud spirit (μεγαλήτωρ θυμός) is not yet appeased (9.500), and he tries again.[37] This time he angrily (κεκοτηότι θυμῷ, 9.501) takes credit for the mutilation of Polyphemus by name (9.502-5), bringing down upon his crew and himself another rock and the anger of Polyphemus’s father, Poseidon (9.526-35). These events may come to mind when Odysseus announces his plan to endure silently the attacks of the suitors and their servants to maintain his disguise (16.274-80) and when he experiences an escalating series of abusive and insulting attacks. This scene demonstrates Odysseus’s inability to endure exactly this kind of abuse and introduces the fear that he will reach his limit among the suitors, rise up, and reveal himself. Such an outcome becomes more plausible as Odysseus’s responses to the suitors gain in confidence (18.376-80, 384-85; 18.389-90), culminating in an encounter with Eurymachus when he “almost gives himself away” (de Jong 2001: 455). This scene also establishes a pattern in which Odysseus achieves success only to face a new threat because of his ignorance and underestimation of an enemy. This pattern threatens to recur when Eurylochus attempts to convince Odysseus that he has successfully taken his revenge and removed the threat of the suitors after killing Antinous alone (22.44-59) and when it is revealed after the murder of the suitors that Odysseus and his allies must now face the suitors’ families, a new, potentially greater threat for which Odysseus has not fully prepared (23.117-22, 130-40).
Circe and Scylla
If the Cyclopeia shows how Odysseus can use cunning to defeat a superior force,[38] his encounters with Circe and Scylla give the impression of a headstrong hero, whose better instincts may fail him in the heat of the moment. When Odysseus divides up his forces to investigate the smoke from Circe’s fire, Eurylochus, not Odysseus, plays the part of the cunning hero. While the others walk into Circe’s trap, Eurylochus stays behind because he suspects deceit (ὀισάμενος δόλον εἶναι, 10.232) and later advises avoiding her altogether (10.266-69). Odysseus’s bravery puts Eurylochus’s cowardice to shame.[39] After hearing Eurylochus’s report, Odysseus arms himself like an Iliadic hero and goes to face the threat head-on (10.261-62). Admirable though Odysseus’s actions may be, Hermes is quick to point out his foolishness. Appearing moments before Odysseus reaches Circe, Hermes chides the hero for coming alone (οἶος) despite being ignorant of the place (χώρου ἄιδρις ἐών, 10.281-82). He makes it clear that Odysseus would have fallen into Circe’s trap like all the rest if not for his intervention (10.284-85).
Odysseus’s encounter with Scylla strengthens the possibility that Odysseus might forget his cunning against the suitors and rush headlong into battle. This time, Odysseus is warned beforehand: when he asks Circe how he might defend against the monster, the goddess mocks him for thinking like a warrior (καὶ δὴ αὖ τοι πολεμήια ἔργα μέμηλε καὶ πόνος, 12.116-17): Scylla will take six men; stopping to fight her is pointless and risks giving her the time to take six more (12.120; 12.121-23). When the time comes, Odysseus forgets Circe’s warning, steering clear of Charybdis but toward Scylla (12.226-27). He arms himself for an epic battle in a way that may have raised “high expectations” that he would win (Hopman 2012: 3, 14-16).[40] In fact, he does not even see Scylla coming and can only bear witness as she devours six of his best men (12.244-59).[41] These scenes show a lack of forethought, a crucial misjudgment of an enemy, and an overreliance on military values. They emphasize the worst qualities Odysseus demonstrated in his encounter with Polyphemus. As Hopman observes, the Scylla scene in particular plants a seed of potential failure for Odysseus’s encounter with the suitors (2012: 24-26).
The Crew
Odysseus’s troubled relationship with his crew has implications for the relationship both to his enemies and to his potential allies in the palace.[42] We find ample evidence in the Apologue of Odysseus’s concern for his men, as when he boldly faces the unknown to save them from Circe and when he cannot believe that she would offer him food when he can think only of their welfare (10.261-62; 383-87).[43] But the Apologue also establishes Odysseus as a loner, who, famously, “did not save his comrades, though he wanted to” (οὐδ᾽ ὣς ἑτάρους ἐρρύσατο, ἱέμενός περ, 1.6). Eurylochus gives voice to the tension between Odysseus and his allies, reminding the crew of the dangers into which Odysseus has already led their crewmates with the Cyclops and accusing him of rashness and recklessness (10.431-37). Odysseus risks making Eurylochus’s case for him when he considers killing Eurylochus despite being related by marriage and needs to be restrained by the other crewmembers (10.438-41). When Odysseus tries to convince his men to sail past Thrinacia to avoid eating the cattle of Helios, it is Eurylochus who argues that Odysseus’s outstanding strength and endurance are exactly what render him unfit to decide for them: he never tires (οὐδέ τι γυῖα κάμνεις) and is “made of iron” (12.279-80); he cannot understand the crews’ exhaustion or fear of sailing in the dark (12.281-90; Cook 1995: 116). Here and elsewhere, Odysseus cannot convince the crew to follow his orders. After he and his men defeat the Ciconians, Odysseus cannot persuade them to leave with their spoils, and they are routed by reinforcements (9.43-45).[44] Despite repeated warnings and solemn oaths, Odysseus cannot stop his crew from eating Helios’ cattle.[45] To the extent that Odysseus’s plan requires manipulating and maneuvering the suitors into place, an inability to exert influence over disobedient young men will prove a barrier to success. The same goes for Odysseus’s allies: as Telemachus becomes increasingly aggressive in his response to the suitors’ abuse despite Odysseus’s injunction against intervening (16.274-77), audience members might recall the disastrous result of Odysseus’s failure to control the crew among the Ciconians or to gauge correctly their limitations on Thrinacia.
Odysseus also shows his crew a “characteristic lack of trust, never telling his men more than is absolutely necessary, always taking delight in his superior knowledge” (Rutherford [1986] 2009: 166).[46] When Aeolus gives Odysseus the bag full of winds (10.19-26), Odysseus trusts no one else to steer the ship, though Elpenor is still alive at this point, and forces himself to stay awake for nine days and nights until he collapses in exhaustion when he sees Ithaca (10.28-33). When the crew begins to plot against him, it becomes clear that Odysseus has concealed the nature of the bag and allowed suspicion and jealousy to fester among his men; the “evil plan” (βουλὴ δὲ κακὴ, 46) they devise in his absence drives them from the shores of Ithaca, back to Aeolus (10.34-49). Odysseus’s unwillingness to share responsibility and information with his allies leads to misfortune in this episode. When it emerges that Odysseus intends to conceal his plan from some members of the household (cf. 16.300-307), audience members may fear a similar outcome. As Penelope in particular begins to make decisions independently of Odysseus’ revenge plan, some might wonder whether her actions will endanger his well-laid plans.
Finally, the encounters with Aeolus and the cattle of the Sun establish a pattern in which Odysseus’s lack of vigilance brings about disaster. The crew is given the opportunity to plot against Odysseus and undo the progress they have made only when Odysseus collapses in exhaustion (10.28-33). On Thrinacia, Eurylochus and the crew plot against him and slaughter the cattle of the Sun (12.340-51) when Odysseus leaves his men to pray but falls asleep (12.335-38). However forgivable, Odysseus’s lack of vigilance in these scenes could look ahead to similar misfortune whenever Odysseus shows a moment’s weakness. Odysseus will be walking a tightrope in the palace where a moment’s carelessness could reveal his identity prematurely and result in his death and the death of his allies. On the basis of this pattern, audience members might wonder what will happen every time Odysseus lays his head down to sleep.
EUMAEUS
As the first of the old acquaintances Odysseus meets on Ithaca, Eumaeus offers a preliminary assessment of Odysseus’s ability to conceal his identity, to test potential allies,[47] and to exercise his cunning in a more realistic setting.[48] As it happens, Eumaeus reveals almost unbidden his hatred of the suitors and devotion to Odysseus (cf. 14.40-44, 61-67, 81-95, 137-47), and Odysseus puts on an impressive and dramatic display of his commitment to disguise. As Odysseus approaches Eumaeus’s hut, he is beset by the four savage dogs the swineherd trained to watch over his pigs (14.29-30). Odysseus sits down and drops the staff (σκῆπτρον) that is his sole means of protection and “would have suffered shameful pain” (κεν…ἀεικέλιον πάθεν ἄλγος) if Eumaeus had not immediately stopped what he was doing and rushed to scare off the dogs with shouts and stones (14.30-36). The poet assures us that Odysseus exposed himself to danger “cleverly” (κερδοσύνῃ, 14.31), and Odysseus’s actions appear to have the desired effect, selling his portrayal of a helpless old man and prompting Eumaeus to demonstrate concern. The scene offers realistic, present-day confirmation of the willingness to risk himself and suffer for the sake of a plan that Odysseus exhibited in the stories of Menelaus and Helen. It looks ahead to the abuse that Odysseus will face from the suitors and offers reassurance that he will show a similar level of commitment to his disguise in the palace. With its high stakes and thin margin of error—Odysseus’s calculation depends not only on Eumaeus’s willingness to help a stranger but also on the time it takes Eumaeus to reach him and Eumaeus’s ability to restrain his dogs—the encounter presages the dangerous balance Odysseus must strike among the suitors.
If Odysseus’s entrance confirms the positive stories about him, his humbling attempt to extract a cloak and tunic from Eumaeus suggest a limit in the real world to Odysseus’s ability to achieve his ends through cunning. For the man whom Athena herself admires for his superior cunning (13.291-95), Odysseus’s attempts to persuade his old swineherd prove surprisingly challenging. Odysseus repeatedly fails to, and in fact never does, convince the swineherd that his master will soon return, and he wins only the use of a cloak for the night. When Eumaeus first accuses Odysseus of being willing to say anything to earn a cloak and tunic (14.131-32), Odysseus proceeds to do just that. He swears and wagers Eumaeus a cloak and tunic that Odysseus will soon appear, payable only upon his return (14.151-64). Eumaeus is unconvinced (14.166-67). When Odysseus crafts a story of great fortune and loss (14.192-359) that includes a rumor of Odysseus’ imminent arrival and a kind host who provides a cloak and tunic, later stolen (14.321-33; 14.320; 341-42), Eumaeus deems the story moving (μοι μάλα θυμὸν ὄρινας, “you greatly stir my heart”) but ultimately unpersuasive (οὐδε με πείσεις, 14.361-65). He will help Odysseus out of respect for Zeus and xenia (14.386-89); there is no need to beguile him with lies (14.387). When Odysseus “tests” Eumaeus (πειρητίζων, 14.459-61) with a story of how Odysseus himself once lied at Troy to supply him with a cloak (14.495-502)[49] and implies that Eumaeus would do the same if the man before him were not old and dressed in rags (14.503-6), Eumaeus calls the story “blameless” (ἀμύμων) and concludes that Odysseus has spoken nothing “inappropriate or unprofitable” (οὐδέ τί πω παρὰ μοῖραν ἔπος νηκερδὲς ἔειπες, 14.508-9).[50] He finally offers Odysseus a spare cloak for the night (14.520-22) and assures him that Telemachus will clothe him when he arrives (14.515-17).[51] Odysseus demonstrates persistence and temporarily solves a problem through cunning, but the cloak is hard won. Odysseus is about to be surrounded by men who want him dead, and he will need to persuade the son who does not know him and others in the palace to risk their lives and stand at his side against the suitors. His powers of persuasion and the efficacy of his stratagems are of the upmost importance. If all of his encounters with enemies and negotiations with allies prove this challenging, victory is hardly close at hand.
ARGOS
The Argos scene is among the most affecting in the epic and offers Odysseus an indication of disorder within the palace,[52] but Argos also poses a twofold challenge to the view that Odysseus is ready to infiltrate the palace and face the suitors in battle. At its core, the brief episode is a reunion between Odysseus and a dear, familiar figure from his past.[53] As Odysseus is about to enter the palace and busy in conversation with Eumaeus (17.290), he walks by an attentive Argos (17.291), the loyal hunting dog he raised before leaving for Troy (17.292-95). Argos immediately recognizes Odysseus and, too weak to approach him (17.303-4), signals his recognition by wagging his tail and lowering his ears (17.301-2).[54] The recognition is mutual; Odysseus cannot help shedding a tear, though he easily avoids Eumaeus’s detection (ῥεῖα λαθών). Feigning ignorance (17.305), he asks Eumaeus about the dog, and Eumaeus explains. As in the case of Odysseus’s tears among the Phaeacians, the emotional content of the scene may distract from its evidentiary value regarding Odysseus’s plans against the suitors. Odysseus’s disguise has thus far proved effective against his swineherd and against the son who never knew him. But Odysseus is returning to the palace where he spent his entire life before leaving for the war and to his wife of many years. Even some of the suitors knew Odysseus when they were children (cf. 21.93-95). Argos’ recognition reminds the audience that those who are better acquainted with Odysseus might see through his disguise and complicate his plans, as in fact happens in the case of Eurycleia. Odysseus’s tears at the sight of Argos may likewise recall his inability to hold back his tears among the Phaeacians, which resulted in the revelation of his identity. Even if Odysseus’s disguise succeeds in preventing his recognition, he might unintentionally identify himself with an emotional display at the sight of loved ones.
The course of Argos’ life also has worrisome implications for Odysseus’s current state. Rose (1979: 222-23) observes a resemblance between the two, arguing that the young “Argos’ superior qualities suggest his master’s,” including his “speed, strength, and especially intelligence and endurance.”[55] In his prime, Argos was amazingly fast, strong and perceptive; he could catch whatever he chased (17.312-18). Yet now, after 20 years, he is lying in manure, covered in parasites, and no longer able to walk (17.296-300, 302-3). The same twenty years have passed for Odysseus, as the epithet ταλασίφρων, “patient”—used here of Odysseus as owner of Argos (17.292) and elsewhere “in contexts that refer to Odysseus' long absence or to his valor at Troy” (Scodel 2005: 401-2)—reminds us. There is no doubt that Odysseus once possessed outstanding physical strength. But Odysseus and others have observed the negative effects that fighting and sailing exert over the years (8.180-83, 17.284-85). Now on Ithaca, Odysseus is playing the part, perhaps too convincingly, of a once-great man ravaged by the effects of time and abuse. Argos provides a moving example of how greatness can fade over time and raises the possibility that Odysseus is no longer the man he once was.[56] The effect is strengthened by frequent allusions in books 17-21 to the strength Odysseus possessed long ago, when he was in his prime (cf. 17.132-37, 537-40; 19.447-54; 21.93-95).
IRUS
Odysseus’s showdown with Irus is the final barrier to taking his place in the palace and addresses directly “whether Odysseus’ strength is what it was in his youth” (Murnaghan [1987] 2011: 61; cf. Steiner 2010: 153) and, for our purposes, whether he possesses the power to face the suitors in battle. The episode follows a dramatic pattern similar to that of the Phaeacian games, in which suspense-inducing doubt is introduced only to be resolved through a satisfying and reassuring demonstration of Odysseus’s strength.[57] Leading up to the fight, the suitors taunt Odysseus and question his physical fitness on the grounds of age (18.31); Odysseus echoes their observations (28.52-53; cf. 8.180-83). Before he agrees to the fight, Odysseus makes the suitors swear an oath and secures the help of Telemachus (18.55-57; 61-65) to ensure that they do not intervene. Some audience members might wonder how Odysseus will fare. Irus is described as large but lacking strength and power (18.3-5). Odysseus is only impersonating an old beggar, but his strength is largely untested; this will be his first fight since the brief encounter with the Ciconians in the Apologue.[58] Signs are promising when Irus and the suitors see Odysseus’s powerful body stripped down in preparation for the fight and realize that they have underestimated him (18.66-81). Suspense is quickly dissipated when, far from being challenged, Odysseus need only consider how badly to defeat Irus in order to maintain his disguise (Steiner 2010: 153) and breaks the bones in Irus’s skull with a single blow (18.90-99). This scene hints at what Odysseus might do to the suitors,[59] and Telemachus later makes the connection explicit when he wishes that the suitors be undone as Irus was (18.235-42). This is the last display of strength prior to the killing of the suitors. It precedes an extended sequence of scenes in which Odysseus must endure their abuse and restrain himself that is likely to heighten anticipation of the revenge. The oath Odysseus makes the suitors swear and the help he receives from Telemachus show the forethought to avoid fighting more enemies at a time than he is able, something he will certainly need against the suitors. In contrast to Odysseus’s experience with the crew in the Apologue, the episode also demonstrates Odysseus’s ability to control and maneuver into place a large group of excited, bloodthirsty young men and to work successfully alongside a young ally. Despite these positive indications, the display is hardly conclusive and the reassurance likely to be short-lived. Irus is a single, physically compromised beggar, not a small army of young men in their prime. Lest one overestimate the value of the display, Melantho points out that defeating an itinerant beggar is hardly something to be excited about: ἦ ἀλύεις, ὅτι Ἶρον ἐνίκησας τὸν ἀλήτην (18.333.36), “are you really excited because you defeated the vagabond, Irus?”
CONCLUSION
The episodes surveyed show how the Odyssey keeps its endpoint in sight and ties together disparate episodes through consistent nods to the revenge plot and incorporation of the qualities, dispositions and skills Odysseus will need to carry it out. Initial indications in the stories of Helen and Menelaus offer a blueprint for Odysseus’s revenge and give the impression that he is perfectly suited for the task. Subsequent episodes frequently offer a combination of reassurance and doubt. Odysseus’s time among the Phaeacians reminds us of his role in devising the Trojan Horse (8.492-95) and shows that he still retains at least some of his old strength but also hints at how nostalgia and a lack of self-control might lead to a recognition by suitors or loved ones. The Apologue illustrates how Odysseus might carry out a revenge plot against a superior force but also reveals a disposition that that could lead to a foolhardy approach, alienate allies, or bring the suitors down upon Odysseus before he has the opportunity to enact his plan. Odysseus’s time with Eumaeus demonstrates the effectiveness of his disguise and ability to enlist allies but suggests limitations to his powers of persuasion. Argos shows how those closest to Odysseus might reveal his identity and how even the most outstanding figures can lose their powers, while Irus offers a final, reassuring test of Odysseus’s physical fitness but acknowledges that Odysseus will face a greater challenge with the suitors. Some of these indications might go unnoticed or come to mind only after the fact. The effect of some episodes might only become evident over repeated performances. But the consistency with which these episodes look ahead to Odysseus’s revenge and address his ability to carry it out suggest that this pattern and the suspense it might evoke played an important part in the composition of the Odyssey as we have it.
We find a similar narrative structure around Odysseus’s reunion with Penelope. Odysseus’s encounters with other women in the epic point now to his undying devotion to Penelope, now to a lack of interest in reuniting with his wife. Odysseus’s rejection of Calypso’s offer of immortality in favor of Ithaca and Penelope offers the strongest evidence of his loyalty to his wife. With its frequent spoken and unspoken allusions to marriage, Odysseus’s time with Nausicaa among the Phaeacians keeps in mind his marriage to Penelope, tests his resolve, and ultimately finds his loyalty intact. In the Apologue, temporally distant but narratively present, Odysseus rejects the pull of the Lotus-eaters and Sirens but becomes so involved with Circe that his crew must drag him away after a year (10.472-74). The effect, I would argue, is neither accidental nor intended to interrogate the double standards surrounding gender roles in Homeric marriage (though it may do this too). It keeps in mind Odysseus’s eventual reunion with Penelope and generates suspense around Odysseus’s motivations, devotion, and worthiness of this desirable outcome.
WORKS CITED
Alden, Maureen. 2017. Para-Narratives in the Odyssey: Stories in Frame. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Anastasova, Maria. 2018. The Suspense of Horror and the Horror of Suspense. Cambridge: Cambridge Scholars Publishing.
Arend, Walter. 1933. Die typischen Scenen bei Homer. Berlin: Weidmann.
Austin, N. 1975. Archery at the Dark of the Moon: Poetic Problems in Homer’s Odyssey. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Bakker, E. J. 1997. Poetry in Speech: Orality and Homeric Discourse. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
— 2013. The Meaning of Meat and the Structure of the Odyssey. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Bowie, A. M. ed. 2013. Odyssey: Books XIII and XIV. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Brelinski, Tim. 2015. “Medon Meets a Cyclops? Odyssey 22.310-80. CQ 65: 1-13.
Brown, C. G. 1996. “In the Cyclops’ Cave: Revenge and Justice in Odyssey 9.” Mnemosyne 49: 1-29.
Burgess, J. S. 2014. “Framing Odysseus: The Death of the Suitors.” In Christopoulos, M. and Païzi-Apostolopoulu, M. eds. Crime and Punishment in Homeric and Archaic Epic, 337-54. Ithaca: Centre for Odyssean Studies.
Carroll, Noël. 2001. Beyond Aesthetics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Clark, Matthew. 2004. “Formulas, Metre and Type-Scenes.” In Fowler, R., ed. The Cambridge Companion to Homer. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Cook, E. F. 1995. The Odyssey in Athens: Myths of Cultural Origins. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
— [1999] 2009. “‘Active’ and ‘Passive’ Heroics in the Odyssey.” In Dohery, L. E. ed. Oxford Readings in Classical Studies: Homer’s Odyssey, 111-134. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
— 2014. “Structure as Interpretation in the Homeric Odyssey.” In Cairns, D. and Scodel, R. eds. Defining Greek Narrative. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
Crane, G. 1987. “The Odyssey and Conventions of the Heroic Quest.” CA 6: 11-37.
de Jong, I. J. F. 2001. A Narratological Commentary on the Odyssey. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Edwards, M. W. 1986. “Homer and Oral Tradition: The Formula. Part I.” Oral Tradition 1: 171-230.
— 1988. “Homer and Oral Tradition: The Formula. Part II.” Oral Tradition 3: 11-60.
— 1992. “Homer and Oral Tradition: The Type Scene.” Oral Tradition 7: 284-330.
Emlyn-Jones, C. 1986. “True and Lying Tales in the Odyssey.” G&R 33: 1-10.
Erbse, H. 1972. Beiträge zum Verständnis der Odyssee. Berlin: De Gruyter.
Felson-Rubin, N. 1994. Regarding Penelope: From Character to Poetics. Norman: University of Oklahoma Press.
Fenik, B. 1974. Studies in the Odyssey. Hermes: Einzelschriften Heft 30. Wiesbaden: F. Steiner.
Fögen, Thorsten. 2017. “Lives in Interaction: Animal “Biographies” in Graeco-Roman Literature?” Fögen, Th. and Thomas, E. eds. In Interactions between Animals and Humans in Graeco-Roman Antiquity, 89-138. Berlin: De Gruyter.
Foley, John. [1997] 2011. Oral Tradition and its Implications.” In Morris, I. and Powell, B. eds. A New Companion to Homer. Leiden: Brill.
Friedrich, Rainer. 1987a. “Heroic Man and Polymetis Odysseus in the Cyclopeia.” GRBS 28: 121-33.
— 1987b. “Thrinakia and Zeus’ Ways to Men in the Odyssey.” GRBS 28: 375-400.
— 1991. “The Hybris of Odysseus.” JHS 111: 16-28.
Gainsford, Peter. 2003. “Formal Analysis of Recognition Scenes in the Odyssey.” JHS 123: 41-59.
Garvie, A. F. 1994. Odyssey: Books VI-VIII. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Goldhill, Simon. 1988. “Reading Differences: The Odyssey and Juxtaposition.” Ramus 17: 1-31.
Hainsworth, J. B. [1981-86] 1998. A Commentary on Homer’s Odyssey, books V-VIII. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Heubeck, Alfred. 1989. “Books IX-XII.” In A Commentary of Homer’s Odyssey, 3-141. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Hoekstra, A. [1984] 1990. Homer’s Odyssey: Books XIII-XVI. In Heubeck, A. et al. A Commentary on Homer’s Odyssey. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Hölscher, Uvo. 1988. Die Odyssee: Epos zwischen Märchen und Roman. Munich: C. H. Beck
Hogan, J. C. 1976. “The Temptation of Odysseus.” TAPA 106: 187-210.
Hogan, P. C. 2003. The Mind and its Stories: Narrative Universals and Human Emotion. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
— 2006. “Narrative Universals, Heroic Tragi-Comedy, and Shakespeare’s Political Ambivalence.” College Literature 33: 34-66.
Hopman, M. 2012. “Narrative and Rhetoric in Odysseus’ Tales to the Phaeacians.” AJP 133: 1-30.
Jensen, M. S. 2017. “The Challenge of Oral Epic to Homeric Scholarship.” Humanities 6.97: 1-15.
Katz, Marylin. 1991. Penelope’s Renown: Meaning and Indeterminacy in the Odyssey. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Kirk, G. S. 1962. The Songs of Homer. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Köhnken, Adolf. 2003. “Perspektivisches Erzählen in homerischen Epos: Die Wiedererkennung Odysseus: Argos.” Hermes 131: 385-96.
Levine, D. B. 1982. “Odyssey 18: Iros as Paradigm for the Suitors.” CJ 77: 200-4.
Lord, A. B. 1960. The Singer of Tales. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Lord, M. 1967. “Withdrawal and Return: An Epic Story Pattern in the Homeric Hymn to Demeter and in the Homeric Poems.” CJ 62: 241-48.
Louden, Bruce. 1993. “An Extended Narrative Pattern in the Odyssey.” GRBS 34: 5-33.
— 1999. The Odyssey: Structure, Narration, and Meaning. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University.
Lowe, N. J. 2000. The Classical Plot and the Invention of Western Narrative. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Minchin, Elizabeth. 2001. Homer and the Resources of Memory: Some Applications of Cognitive Theory to the Iliad and the Odyssey. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
— 2019. “Odysseus, Emotional Intelligence, and the Plot of the Odyssey.” Mnemosyne 72: 351-68.
Morrison, J.V. 1992. Homeric Misdirection: False Predictions in the Iliad. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
Most, G. W. 1989. “The Structure and Function of Odysseus’ Apologoi.” TAPA 119: 15-30.
Murnaghan, Sheila. [1986] 2009. “Penelope’s Agnoia: Knowledge, Power, and Gender in the Odyssey.” In Doherty, L E. ed. Oxford Readings in Classical Studies: Homer’s Odyssey, 231-46. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
— [1987] 2011. Disguise and Recognition in the Odyssey. Lanham: Lexington Books.
Nagler, M. N. 1974. Spontaneity and Tradition: A Study in the Oral Art of Homer. Berkeley: University of California Press.
— [1977] 1996. “Dread Goddess Revisited.” In Schein, S. L. ed. Reading the Odyssey: Selected Interpretive Essays, 141-62. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
— 1990. “The Proem and the Problem.” CA 9: 335-56.
Newton, R. M. 1998. “Cloak and Shield in Odyssey 14.” CJ 93: 143-156.
Olson, S. D. 1989. “The Stories of Helen and Menelaus (Odyssey 4.240-89) and the Return of Odysseus.” AJP 110: 387-94.
— 1990. “The Stories of Agamemnon in Homer’s Odyssey.” TAPA 120: 57-71.
— 1995. In Blood and Iron: Stories and Storytelling in Homer’s Odyssey. Leiden: Brill.
Ortony, Andrew, Clore, G. L., and Collins, Allan. 1998. The Cognitive Structure of Emotions. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Page, D. 1955. The Homeric Odyssey. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Powell, B. B. 1977. Composition by Theme in the Odyssey. Meisenheim am Glan: Hain.
Race, W. H. 1993. “First Appearances in the Odyssey.” TAPA 123: 79-107
Reece, Steve. 1993. The Stranger’s Welcome: Oral Theory and the Aesthetics of the Homeric Hospitality Scene. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
— 1995. “The Three Circuits of the Suitors: A Ring Composition in Odyssey 17-22.” Oral Tradition 10: 207-229.
Reinhardt, Karl. [1948] 1996. “The Adventures in the Odyssey.” In Schein, S. L. ed. Reading the Odyssey: Selected Interpretive Essays, 63-133. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Rinon, Y. 2006. “Mise en abyme and Tragic Signification in the Odyssey: The Three Songs of Demodocus.” Mnemosyne 59: 208-25.
Rose, G. P. 1969. “The Unfriendly Phaeacians.” TAPA 100: 387-406.
— 1979. “Odysseus’ Barking Heart.” TAPA 109: 215-30.
Rutherford, R. B. [1986] 2009. “The Philosophy of the Odyssey.” In Doherty, L E. ed. Oxford Readings in Classical Studies: Homer’s Odyssey, 155-88. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Saïd, S. [1998] 2011. Homer and the Odyssey. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Schein, S. L. 1996. “Introduction.” In Schein, S. L. ed. Reading the Odyssey: Selected Interpretive Essays, 3-31. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Schmitz, Th. A. 1994. “Ist die Odyssee “spannend”? Anmerkungen zur Erzähltechnik des homerischen Epos.” Philologus 138: 3-23.
Scodel, Ruth. 1998. “The Removal of the Arms, the Recognition with Laertes, and Narrative Tension in the Odyssey.” CP 93: 1-17.
— 2004. “The Story-Teller and his Audience.” In Fowler, R. ed. The Cambridge Companion to Homer, 45-55. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
— 2005. “Odysseus’ Dog and the Productive Household.” Hermes 133: 401-8.
Segal, C. P. 1992. “Divine Justice in the Odyssey: Poseidon, Cyclops, and Helios.” AJP 113: 489-518.
Seland, Andreas. 2018. Divine Suspense: On Kierkegaard’s Frygt Og Bæven” and the Aesthetics of Suspense. Berlin: De Gruyter.
Slatkin, L. M. 1996. “Composition by Theme and the Mētis of the Odyssey.” In Schein, S. L. ed. Reading the Odyssey: Selected Interpretive Essays, 223-238. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Stanford, W. B. [1954] 1963. The Ulysses Theme: A Study in the Adaptability of a Traditional Hero. Oxford: Blackwell.
Stanford, W. B. ed. [1948] 1965. The Odyssey of Homer, 2 vols. New York: St. Martin’s.
Steiner, Deborah. 2009. “Diverting Demons: Ritual, Poetic Mockery and the Odysseus-Iros Encounter.” CA 28: 71-100.
—. ed. 2010. Homer: Odyssey, Books XVII and XVIII. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Sternberg, M. [1973] 1978. Expositional Modes and Temporal Ordering in Fiction. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press.
Tracy, S. V. 1997. “The Structures of the Odyssey.” In Morris, I. and Powell, B. eds. A New Companion to Homer, 360-79. Leiden: Brill.
Trahman, C. R. 1952. “Odysseus’ Lies (Odyssey, Books 13-19).” Phoenix 6: 31-43.
West, S. [1981] 1998. A Commentary on Homer’s, Books I-IV. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Wright, Tim. 2018. “Telemachus’ Recognition of Odysseus.” GRBS 58: 1-18.
[1] I would like to thank Martin Hose and all of my readers for helpful suggestions that strengthened the arguments presented here.
[2] Cf. Lord [1960] 2000: 25, Jensen 2017: 7.
[3] See Edwards 1986, 1988, 1992; Foley [1997] 2011; Clark 2004 for useful overviews of oral techniques with references.
[4] Note, however, Parry’s and Lord’s early “experiments” with South Slavic singers that resulted in expanded songs (Lord [1960] 2000: 78) and see Lord [1960] 2000: 78-81, 102-5, 223-34 on expansion and “ornament.”
[5] For the importance of suspense and “tension” in the Odyssey, see, for instance, Sternberg 1978: 65, 244; Fenik 1974: 104; 55, 60; Schmitz 1994; Scodel 1998; Lowe 2000: 154-56.
[6] See, for instance, Hopman 2012: 23 on the “key” function of embedded narratives, Austin 1975: 162 on “paradigms for the restitution of order on Ithaca” in the Apologue, and Nagler 1990 for important parallels between the crew and the suitors.
[7] See Lord 1960: 159-97, M. Lord 1967, Nagler 1974: 131-66, Fenik 1974, Powell 1977: 1, Edwards 1992: 286, Slatkin 1996, Bakker 2013: 21n2.
[8] Cf. Louden 1993. Ring-composition leads to repetitions within its mirrored sequences but would be unlikely to lead to the kind of widespread repetitions with which this article is interested. See Tracy 1997, Reece 1995: 207-8, Bakker 1997: 115, Minchin 2001: 181-202, Cook 2014: 75. Type scenes lead to repetitions but would likewise be more limited in scope than the kinds of repetition treated here. See Arend 1933, Edwards 1992, Clark 2004 for a list of type scenes.
[9] For Alden 2017: 2-8, para-narratives include “analogous or parallel situations…so that one episode resembles and sheds light on another” and paradigmatic speeches and story shapes that provide models for future action and paradigms for judging characters and situations.
[10] Alden considers the stories of Helen and Menelaus and the entire Apologue as “para-narratives.”
[11] See, e.g., Alden 2017: 75, 5 and cf. Most 1989, who argues that the Apologue serves a rhetorical function for Odysseus in relation to the Phaeacians.
[12] See Schmitz 1994: 10-15 for evidence in the Odyssey of tension generated through the possibility of untraditional outcomes for Odysseus’s story. Cf. Felson-Rubin 1994: x on her inclusion of “possible plots” for analysis, often “expressed as hopes or fears, and situational parallels. See Morrison 1992: 6-7, 1-8 on misdirection in the Iliad.
[13] See Smuts 2008: 282 on the “standard account” of suspense according to Ortony, Clore and Collins 1998: 131. See Smuts 2008, Anastasova 2018: 6-20 for other theories of suspense.
[14] See Carroll 2001, Smuts 2008, Seland 2018: 25-32 for attempts to explain why audiences appear to experience the emotions associated with suspense despite knowing the outcome of a situation, the so-called “paradox of suspense.” This phenomenon might also explain how audience members could experience suspense despite knowing (or believing they know) the outcome of the story based on the tradition.
[15] Hogan 2003: 11, 94 attributes “universal narrative structures” across cultures to their protagonists’ seeking out universal “prototypes for the eliciting conditions of happiness”: the desire for “romantic union” leads to romans, the desire for “social or political power (including material prosperity)” leads to heroic stories, tragic if the protagonists fail, comic if they succeed. See also Hogan 2006. See Schmitz 1994 for concerns regarding definitions of suspense that do not address cultural and generic differences.
[16] See Carroll 2001: 261-62 both on the variety of protagonists for which one might feel “allegiance” and of the “virtues, including pagan virtues” that draw audiences to them. These requirements open up the possibility that Odysseus might be seen to “fail” even if the Odyssey adheres to tradition because of the means he employs to kill the suitors. See Burgess 2014 for an examination of the ethical ambiguity of the revenge.
[17] Cf. Sternberg 1978: 61, Clay [1983] 1997: 34-38, Murnaghan [1987] 2011: 67n13, Lowe 2000: 142 on how the portrayal of the suitors invites approval of Odysseus’s actions.
[18] With its elements of return, betrayal, surprise and ambush, the account of the murder of Agamemnon by Aegisthus and Clytemnestra (11.409-26) presents both pitfalls Odysseus must avoid and techniques he might utilize in carrying out his revenge. For the use of Agamemnon’s story to forecast positive and negative outcomes for Odysseus and to generate suspense in the Odyssey, see D’Arms and Hulley 1946: 212, S. West [1981] 1998: 60, Olson 1990, Katz 1991: 41-52, de Jong 2001: 12-14, Scodel 2004: 54-55, Alden 2017: 77-100.
[19] Telemachus doubts their chances if there were only ten or twenty suitors (16.241-45), and the suitors cannot believe that Odysseus intends to attack them because “who would think…that one man among many feasters, even if he were very mighty, would bring about an evil death and dark doom for himself (τίς κ' οἴοιτο μετ' ἀνδράσι δαιτυμόνεσσι | μοῦνον ἐνὶ πλεόνεσσι, καὶ εἰ μάλα καρτερὸς εἴη, | οἷ τεύξειν θάνατόν τε κακὸν καὶ κῆρα μέλαιναν, 22.12-14). But cf. the view of Athena at 13.393.
[20] A poet intending to expand upon the story of Hephaestus’s revenge, for example, might introduce episodes that test Hephaestus’s ability to detect betrayal, to surprise and deceive, to overcome a superior force (e.g., Zeus in Iliad 1), or to devise cunning inventions.
[21] For parallels between the stories of Menelaus and Helen and Odysseus’s experience in the palace, see Erbse 1972: 96-97, S. West [1981] 1998: ad 4.244, Rutherford [1986] 2009: 169, Crane 1987: 28, Olson 1989: 391, Katz 1991: 79, Saïd [1998] 2011: 112, 269, de Jong 2001: 101-2, Alden 2017: 5, 158-65, 171. Sternberg [1973]: 75 and Olson 1995: 83 see these stories as advertisement for Odysseus’s heroic qualities. Wright 2018: 11 concludes that they show “Odysseus is well equipped to deal with the situation on Ithaca” and “how… [Telemachus’s] vengeful fantasy (1.114-117) could become reality.”
[22] See Alden 2017: 166-67, 166n55 for parallels between the two scenes and the roles played by Helen, Eurycleia and Penelope.
[23] See Rose 1969, Most 1989: 27, Reece 1993: 101-21, Hopman 2012: 21-22 on indications that the Phaeacians may prove “unfriendly” to Odysseus, including their devotion to Poseidon, the intervention of Athena and their distaste for strangers.
[24] This is an athletic competition, not a battle, and Alcinous undercuts Odysseus’s achievement when he emends his previous claims about the Phaeacians: they are better runners, sailors, musicians and dancers than boxers or wrestlers (8.246-49; cf. 8.100-3).
[25] See de Jong 2001: 199 on how the Phaeacians’ abuse prefigures the suitors’.
[26] Garvie 1994: 275 notes that the scholiasts believed the Odysseus’s reference to his suffering “is designed to provide an excuse for possible failure, and to increase the admiration that success will arouse.”
[27] See Reinhardt [1948] 1996: 126; Fenik 1974: 22, 54-55, 153-54; Reece 1993: 198; de Jong 2001: 150 for how Odysseus’s time among the Phaeacians foreshadows the conclusion of the Odyssey.
[28] See Reinhardt [1948] 1996: 126 on the patterns of disguise and recognition established on Scheria and Ithaca.
[29] Odysseus also holds back his tears in the presence of Telemachus (cf. 16.191).
[30] Austin 1975: 162 sees in the Apologue “paradigms for the restitution of order on Ithaca.”
[31] See Alden 2017: 233-46 for similarities between the suitors and the Cyclops, whose impiety, gluttony, deceptiveness, shamelessness serves as a monstrous caricature of the suitors’. See Cook 1995: 97, 1999: 165, Saïd [1998] 2011: 252, Hopman 2012: 24, Brelinski 2015 for parallels between the Cyclops episode and the murder of the suitors. Brelinski 2015: 3 and Alden 2017: 233 note that the Odyssey itself draws a parallel to the Cyclops episode prior to the slaughter of the suitors in lines 20.18-21. See Brelinski 2015 for other references to the Cyclopeia in the second half of the Odyssey.
[32] See Page 1955: 8, Saïd [1998] 2011: 228, de Jong 2001: 237 on Odysseus’s foresight before his encounter with Polyphemus and the Laestrygonians.
[33] See Friedrich 1987b: 394, 1991: 23; Cook 1995: 109, Hopman 2012: 6 for the Cylcopeia as a paradigmatic display of Odysseus’s metis.
[34] Cf. Reinhardt [1948] 1996: 79-81, Schein 1996: 30. Cook 1995: 99 notes that Goat Island removes the need for food and highlights Odysseus’s selfish motivations. See also Bakker 2013: 60-64.
[35] Cf. Eurylochus’s accusation that Odysseus’s rashness (θρασύς) and recklessness (τούτου … ἀτασθαλίηισιν) for the deaths that result from this decision (10.435-37).
[36] See Kirk 1962: 364-65, Rutherford [1986] 2009: 166, Friedrich 1987a, Segal 1992: 494 for negative assessments of the boast. Reinhardt [1948] 1996: 83 and Friedrich 1991: 26 see hybris in Odysseus’s claim to have executed divine justice (cf. Brown 1996). Cook [1999] 2009 considers Odysseus right to claim divine justice but wrong to assert that Poseidon cannot heal his son (see also Friedrich 1991: 21, 25; Segal 1992: 505).
[37] Friedrich 1987a interprets this scene as an expression of the boastful, Iliadic aspect of Odysseus’s heroism.
[38] See Alden 2017: 224, who offers the nuanced view that “the Cyclops story functions on one level for the poet’s audience as a pattern for the means to defeat the suitors: μῆτις will more than compensate for inferior physical force, but must be harnessed to βίη to achieve an effective victory.”
[39] Cf. Hogan 1976: 195, according to whom, “[t]he first scouting party’s enchantment leads to a test of Odysseus’ loyalty to his men, a point effectively dramatized by Eurylochos’ failure of nerve.”
[40] See also Heubeck 1989: 130-311; Rutherford [1986] 2009: 166, 168; Cook [1999] 2009: 119, 133; Alden 2017: 67, on the Iliadic nature of the scene.
[41] See Rutherford [1986] 2009: 168, Crane 1987: 31-32.
[42] See Nagler [1977] 1996: 154, Heubeck 1989: 10-11, Cook 1995: 120, Louden 1999: xiii, Steiner 2010: 18 for the resemblance between Odysseus’s crew and the suitors.
[43] See de Jong 2001: 223 on Odysseus’s “characteristic solicitude as a leader: he is always trying to save his men and is greatly grieved when he loses one of them…” See also Reinhardt [1948] 1996: 91.
[44] For Rutherford [1986] 2009: 165, this is “the keynote of Odysseus’ difficult relations with his followers.”
[45] See Fenik 1974: 208-30, Friedrich 1987b, Segal 1992, de Jong 2001: 305-7 on Odysseus’s inability to control his men in this episode.
[46] Cf. his selective sharing of information regarding Scylla (12.223-25).
[47] See de Jong 2001: ad 16.304-20 for the theme of Odysseus’s testing his servants.
[48] Stanford [1948] 1965: 2.li, Hölscher 1988, Hoekstra [1984] 1990: 148.
[49] See Newton 1998, Lowe 2000: 145-47, Bowie 2013: 223.
[50] See Trahman 1952: 37-39; Emlyn-Jones 1986: 6-7; de Jong 2001: 352-55 and App. E; Bowie 2013: 193-94; Alden 2017: 279-83 on how Odysseus’s tales are designed to appeal to Eumaeus.
[51] See de Jong 2001: ad 14.122-32 on “the ‘gift of clothes’ motif” as it develops during the second half of the Odyssey. Newton 1998: 152-3 stresses that Odysseus does not persuade Eumaeus or win a cloak. See Minchin 2019: 358-59 for a positive assessment of Odysseus’s ability to win sympathy with his “emotional intelligence.”
[52] See Race 1993: 99-100, Köhnken 2003, Scodel 2005, Steiner 2010: 116-18, Fögen 2017: 93-98.
[53] Gainsford 2003: 57 works to distinguish the Argos scene from other recognitions, but see Köhnken 2003: 393.
[54] See the discussion of Köhnken 2003: 390-91.
[55] See also Goldhill 1988: 17, Steiner 2010: 117.
[56] Köhnken 2003: 391, 93 sees Argos as a metaphor for Odysseus’s fate in the sense that they are equally forgotten by their household.
[57] See Steiner 2010: 16, 153 for similarities between Odysseus’s encounter with Irus and with Euryalus in Odyssey 8.
[58] Odysseus considers attacking Melanthius but checks himself (ἐπετόλμησε, φρεσὶ ἔσχετο, 17.238).
[59] See Levine 1982; Nagler 1990: 349; de Jong 2001: 437-38; Scodel 2004: 49; Steiner 2009: 72, 2010: 16.